KELVIN'S BLOG: Financial Review advancing fringe position

KELVIN'S BLOG: Financial Review advancing fringe position

As MacroBusiness points out, fewer than 20% of New South Wales residents want New South Wales' population to increase, according to a 2019 Newspoll.


On Tuesday 12 October the Financial Review ran as its front page story, "Migrant boost to stir recovery", with a bolded bullet point reading "NSW mandarins urge five-year doubling of annual pre-COVID 19 immigration to 400,000".

The article reported advice by the NSW Department of Premier and Cabinet to incoming Premier Perrotet. It said “In a sign the new Premier is taking the advice seriously, Mr Perrotet yesterday said the borders need to be opened up amid a 'general labour' shortage to ensure a healthy economic recovery".

The proposal was widely condemned. On Friday the Financial Review had decided that opposition to the proposal was overly simplistic, and that "no government is going to allow in 2 million people in five years".

Is that so? Then why did the Financial Review give the proposal front page treatment on Tuesday? Why did it say not a word then about the proposal being fanciful? Why did it report that the Premier was “taking the advice seriously”?

The Financial Review on Friday also sought to suggest that opposition to the proposal was coming from the political fringe, by putting up Pauline Hanson as their straw man opponent of the idea.

The truth is that opposition to the proposal is widespread and mainstream. It is the Department of Premier and Cabinet, and the Financial Review, which are advancing a fringe position.

As MacroBusiness points out, fewer than 20% of New South Wales residents want New South Wales' population to increase, according to a 2019 Newspoll. And fewer than 20% of Australians want our net migration rate to go back to 240,000, let alone 400,000, according to research just last week from The Australian Population Research Institute.

The two Financial Review articles would make a good subject for the ABC’s Media Watch. But Media Watch has its blind spots too, and the Population Ponzi is one of them.

The Hon. Kelvin Thomson
National Committee
Sustainable Australia Party
@HonKelThomson

Recent responses